The Inside Assyria Discussion Forum #5

=> Re: BRING US HISTORIANS!!!!! NOT GRANDMOTHERS!!!!

Re: BRING US HISTORIANS!!!!! NOT GRANDMOTHERS!!!!
Posted by pancho (Moderator) - Friday, April 26 2013, 19:27:27 (UTC)
from *** - *** Mexico - Windows NT - Mozilla
Website:
Website title:

>And why would we trust a sculptor that hate his own people

...where is the evidence that I "hate my own people"? My people are the people on this planet...we're not in the schoolyard choosing teams. Did you think it was "hate" that made your mother tell you not to put your mashed potatoes in your nose?


to enlight us with what is real evidence and whats not?


...I just bring you the sources...you decide. I wish you gave us that option.


You ask for evidence from real scholars they gave you simo parpola and you acuse him of being bought by the assyrians than they give you David Gaunt you ask who it is and reply ".we would have to know who Gaunt is...if he is religious, then his "book" is highly suspect...give us an actual historian" And when you find out who he is you answer"...it never ceases to amaze me, I mean the self-hatred we assyrians feel for ourselves


...you do not present an historian of pre-Colombian(before Columbus) America when seeking facts about the Second World War...you seek scholars in THAT field. Parpola is a respected Assyriologist who is an amateur and non-professional when it comes to the history of modern-day assyrian claims....if you want those facts, you go to Dr Joseph, like the U.S. State Department does...you go the one who STUDIED and has been recognized in the field....Joseph would never dream of writing, as an expert, on ancient Assyrian history because it is not his field...Paropla, and Gaunt too, know they have a cash cow, though a poor one, in this community of ours...and so they stroke our nuts....however, NO source, no serious academic source speaks of the existence of modern day assyrians as FACT...they might mention it as something WE believe, but that is all...only Wikipedia, as a "source", cites the existence of modern day assyrians...no other encyclopedia bothers with such nonsense, because it IS nonsense...ask yourself why.


....here is netreino, among othersm bring before us another Euro, David gaunt, and presenting him as a reliable source on the modern history of our community...Gaunt is an Assyriologis who chose modern assyrians and their "genocide" as a hobby...most likely because he could get funding from various religious and assyrian sources...again, it's "ball-stroking" time. You didnt know shit about him and what he dose but you took a stab at him anyway

...I saw him and heard him give a talk at an assyrian convention...nothing he said was convincing or would meet the requirements of anyone BUT assyrians at a convention. We "like him" because we like what he says about us...on that basis you can't get a high school degree let alone a PhD.


>Aina is no good eather no one can chalange you because your so smart,

...bring us HISTORIANS....SCHOLARS...REAL encyclopedias in THIS FIELD. No amateurs, no "nice guys" and no AINA...AINA is the worst of all of them.

Why, I simply HAVE to ask, can you not do this? Why? Where are they? I gave you Toynbee, Gibbon and Durant, and will add Joseph and in return all you can bring is NON-experts in the field and something called AINA...is this really the BEST you can do?

I guess so.


but tell us what is your credential where did you study and who gave you a almighty diploma that covers every topic in the world?

...nowhere. I dropped out of school in the third grade to support a gambling addiction...but, the people I BRING you are among the most respected, in their field, scholars the world has produced...unlike you I don't try to pass off my opinions as history, or fact...I comment AFTER or around, but what I place in the CENTER are the words of others far more qualified then me in every way...and this is something you CAN'T do...all you have for us are YOUR opinions plus a grandmother here or there, some toadying Europeans and AINA...and yes, that is the BEST you can do.

One thing your good at and thats schulpting you make me proud to be Assyrian when i se the majestic statues you make

...you have no reason to be proud as an assyrian, because you aren't one and neither am I. Those sculptures honor the ancient Assyrians, not you. In fact your behavior here shows what an insult you are to the memory of the real Assyrians...

..one last time: Bring us the name of a REPUTABLE expert in THIS field, and present his facts and evidence...we don;t need to hear any more about your opinions...just bring us an expert, kay?



---------------------


The full topic:



***



Powered by RedKernel V.S. Forum 1.2.b9