The Inside Assyria Discussion Forum #5

=> Re: Sargon Donabed....

Re: Sargon Donabed....
Posted by pancho (Moderator) - Friday, May 17 2013, 21:15:04 (UTC)
from *** - *** Commercial - Windows NT - Mozilla
Website:
Website title:

Taoro wrote:
>Wow you realy getting exited but take it easy so that your heart dosent stop from all the excitment finaly you think that you found something that can finish me of...

...what "finishes you off" is the fact that you can't find any real books...and even if we allow this one book..it is ONE book. Why, when there are so many books on our side, do you have so much trouble finding more?

The book is interdisciplinary there are 13 i think chapters and 13 writers from diffrent areas concerning the assyrians and one of them is religion,

...given your performance here I don;t think you know what "interdisciplinary" is...what "different areas"? See, when you LIKE something, you don't ask any further, you don;t question...assyrian writers, means nothing....WHO are they? WHAT standing do they have? And, if you read the areas of study at Upsalla, they are ALL religious...not one of them was anything BUT religious...I can post it for you again if you like.


it is realy easy for someone like you to follow, they go trough history pointing out why we claim that we are assyrians.

..it is a RELIGIOUS site...we told you from the beginning not to bring us anything from a religious source


And for the publishing house it belongs to one of swedens most renowned universitys and isnt a religious university but all this you probably know but your propaganda is like this you show what suits you to make your point like for example that i brought a tracian

...I copied the department at that Swedish university...I posted it above...you find me ONE area mentioned that is NOT religious...go on, just ONE.


or what you call it professor I dont even know what you are talking about, but it fits your litte argument so you use it true or not, lucky for me people can read if they want to bother with you and se for them self.

...the people who can read can see that even when we allow your silly book...you can find only ONE...and Donabed is a hsitorian of RELIGION...which is not the same as being a historian of HISTORY...you know, like Toynbee and Durant and Gibbon, to name only a few. You have yet to find one actual historian in THIS field of equal, or even near, standing with Joseph...not one.

Joseph would never write in Donabed's field of expertise, because he knows he is not academically qualified...but Donabed has no problem writing outside his area....this is the difference between scholarship and propaganda.

Plus which I have posted extensively from Joseph...not MY words but his...how come you can't manage to do the same with Donabed's works..or anyone else's? Have you even READ any of these? Are you afraid to quote Donabed?



---------------------


The full topic:



***



Powered by RedKernel V.S. Forum 1.2.b9