The Inside Assyria Discussion Forum #5

=> Re: where are the facts about alleged Muslim atrocities????

Re: where are the facts about alleged Muslim atrocities????
Posted by pancho (Moderator) - Sunday, April 7 2013, 15:19:55 (UTC)
from *** - *** Mexico - Windows NT - Mozilla
Website:
Website title:

nestrieno wrote:
>dear pancho i do not want to have controversy with you on that subject, my knowledge about all that is not as great as yours.

...I had no knowledge at all either until I went out and got it...which anyone can do. If you don't want to bother, that's okay....but you should not spread such vile accusations, without solid evidence. It loses you the respect of serious people and wins you only the praise of the ignorant.


as i told you if one day i have more reliable informations i shall share with you. the only ones i have for the moment are testinonies of surviving people.

...I'm afraid that doesn't support the claims, especially as there are no survivors of the alleged forcible conversions which took place hundreds of years ago....I agree that there were murders and massacres, but this is not the same as genocide, a Holocaust or even government ordered exterminations....my great-grandfather was murdered...he was not "martyred" and no one tried to convert him to Islam...they just killed him which, I agree with you, everyone has done to everyone, but those are not the claims...the claims made by us are that we were forcibly converted to Islam on pain of death and were murdered JUST for our religion..it is these two in particular that I am challenging, and so far, as you can see, no evidence has been produced.

what i can say without doubt is that there was massacres tortures murdered committed both by chritians and muslims. other informations can be found in the book "massacres resistance, protectors" by David Gaunt .

.we would have to know who Gaunt is...if he is religious, then his "book" is highly suspect...give us an actual historian.
>
>about your great uncle babadjan Malek, my grand father refers many times about him as captain babadjan Malek. in 1918 when a detachment of assyrian troops left ourmia to meet the british at Sain khala (to obtain help munitions furnitures...!!) babadjan malek was one of them.

...I was with my great-uncle just before he died....he would weep at times uncontrollably and when my mother asked why he said he could remember all the faces of the men he'd had to kill...especially one time when he personally executed over 20 Kurds who'd tried to assassinate the Agha...my mother told him it was war time and God understood...but he wouldn't be comforted and cried like a child....you never escape the effects of murdering people...never.
>
>cordialy yours

...and yours.



---------------------


The full topic:



***



Powered by RedKernel V.S. Forum 1.2.b9